Integrity under stress: diagnosing the capture of integrity instruments and designing for their resilience in non-ODA contexts
Integrity Under Stress examines how the instruments that democracies use to prevent corruption and undue influence, from freedom of information laws to beneficial ownership registers and anti-SLAPP rules, can themselves be captured or repurposed, and which design choices make them more resilient.
Project Summary
Democracies rely on a growing repertoire of integrity instruments to keep public decision-making free from undue influence. These include for example political finance rules, freedom of information regimes, public consultation procedures, lobbying registers, beneficial ownership registers, open contracting frameworks or protections against strategic lawsuits against public participation (SLAPPs). Each instrument has its own architecture, with specific rules on who controls access, who can trigger and direct enforcement, what must be disclosed and how much discretion officials hold. That architecture also creates specific vulnerabilities. An instrument can be controlled by the actors it is meant to constrain, turned against the watchdogs it was meant to protect, or tactically repurposed for rent seeking by actors it was never meant to serve. The project’s particular focus is on such deliberate, tactical misuse of instruments for political advantage or financial gain. Conventional monitoring, which tracks whether instruments exist and are used, can misread these situations as signs of good governance.
The evidence on these vulnerabilities is scattered across public administration research, political science, administrative law, business strategy and anti-corruption research, and has not yet been brought together and examined as a common class of problems. This project takes the individual instrument as its unit of analysis. Focusing on three to four instruments, selected through a structured scoping review and weighted towards newer tools whose design features are still being refined, it maps where and how capture occurs, examines instruments that held up under pressure, and derives design options that practitioners and standard-setters can use. The project concentrates on established non-ODA democracies. Many of these instruments were first developed there and most standard-setting institutions are based there, while populism, polarisation, shrinking civic space and eroding political norms are putting them under additional strain.
The project runs from October 2026 to May 2027, is hosted by the Università della Svizzera italiana (USI), Lugano, and forms part of GI-ACE’s work on state capture, adding an instrument-level perspective to existing research on how capture operates and how countries can build resilience against or recover from it.
Policy and Programming Implications
The project is designed to equip practitioners with a practical diagnostic and design resource rather than merely a catalogue of failures. Its principal output is a structured map of capture risks and design options, organised by instrument and type of capture risk, which grades the strength of evidence behind each option and distinguishes findings replicated across jurisdictions from single-case observations and practitioner assessments.
Three implications are expected to be of particular interest. First, for newer instruments such as beneficial ownership registers, open contracting frameworks and anti-SLAPP protections, safeguards can still be built in at relatively low cost while templates and standards are evolving. Second, design choices involve trade-offs: closing one route to capture can open another, and reducing official discretion by default can produce rigid rules that sophisticated actors learn to work around. The map addresses these trade-offs explicitly. Third, a set of instrument-level early warning indicators, such as shifts in enforcement patterns, changes to standing rules or alterations to appointment procedures, can help detect capture pressure before it becomes entrenched and can complement existing monitoring frameworks.
The project treats political feasibility as a research question in its own right, asking which design changes are viable under which conditions. Findings will be fed into ongoing policy processes, including the implementation of the UNCAC resolution on transparency in political finance, the OECD’s work with lobbying regulators and Open Government Partnership communities of practice, and are relevant to instruments prioritised in the UK Anti-Corruption Strategy 2025.
Research Implications
The project focuses on three to four integrity instruments, chosen in consultation with GI-ACE and weighted towards newer tools whose design is still being settled. For these instruments, it asks:
- Where are these instruments open to exploitation? Which features of their design, such as who controls access, who can trigger enforcement, what must be disclosed and how much discretion officials hold, leave room for them to be captured, turned against their intended users or tactically repurposed for private gain?
- Who exploits these openings, and under what political conditions? Do similar tactics recur across different instruments, which would allow common safeguards rather than piecemeal fixes?
- Why do some instruments hold up under pressure when others give way? What can instruments that kept working despite documented attempts to capture them teach us about the design features and institutional arrangements that make them resilient?
- What can practitioners and standard-setters realistically change? Which design options are backed by evidence, what trade-offs do they carry, and under what political and administrative conditions can they be adopted?
Methodology
The project combines a review of existing evidence with new insights from practitioners. It first brings together what is already known, from several academic disciplines and from practitioner sources, about how integrity instruments are exploited and which design features help them hold up. A survey of 30 to 40 expert practitioners in 12 to 15 countries adds knowledge that has not yet reached the published record.
The project then compares how the selected instruments work across different jurisdictions. It pays particular attention to instruments that kept functioning despite pressure, using a small number of interviews where cases need closer study. Practitioners are also involved through an online innovation workshop where the design options are tested and further developed with standard-setting organisations.
Research Team Members
Dr Dieter Zinnbauer, Principal Investigator
Faculty Fellow, Copenhagen Business School; Università della Svizzera italiana, Lugano
Prof. Dr Jean-Patrick Villeneuve, Co-Principal Investigator
Professor of Public Administration and Management and Director of the Public Integrity Research Group (GRIP), Università della Svizzera italiana, Lugano
